Close Menu
World Forbes – Business, Tech, AI & Global Insights
  • Home
  • AI
  • Billionaires
  • Business
  • Cybersecurity
  • Education
    • Innovation
  • Money
  • Small Business
  • Sports
  • Trump
What's Hot

Franck Sorbier fuses Andean splendor with Parisian pageantry

July 9, 2025

The 5 best vehicles for campers, according to Edmunds

July 9, 2025

Trump’s big bill cuts Medicaid, SNAP: How it could affect babies

July 9, 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • Franck Sorbier fuses Andean splendor with Parisian pageantry
  • The 5 best vehicles for campers, according to Edmunds
  • Trump’s big bill cuts Medicaid, SNAP: How it could affect babies
  • A simple recipe for tsukudani, an everyday Japanese side dish to eat with hot rice
  • Tsukudani and hot rice: A go-to meal in Japan for centuries
  • Faith-based camps like those hit by Texas floods are rite of passage for many
  • Armani couture channels black as maestro misses Paris bow for 1st time, days from 91st birthday
  • Mamdani Doesn’t Think We Should Have Billionaires. Here’s Why That Will Never Happen.
World Forbes – Business, Tech, AI & Global InsightsWorld Forbes – Business, Tech, AI & Global Insights
Thursday, July 10
  • Home
  • AI
  • Billionaires
  • Business
  • Cybersecurity
  • Education
    • Innovation
  • Money
  • Small Business
  • Sports
  • Trump
World Forbes – Business, Tech, AI & Global Insights
Home » Tennessee’s GOP leads the fight to deny public education to children without documents
Education

Tennessee’s GOP leads the fight to deny public education to children without documents

adminBy adminApril 17, 2025No Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Telegram Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email
Post Views: 54


NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Damian Felipe Jimenez has many dreams about his future — he could be a restaurant owner, a scientist or maybe something else. As he works through sixth grade, he knows education will be critical in making his dreams a reality, but he’s increasingly worried that option could soon disappear for some of his classmates.

Felipe Jimenez is one of hundreds of children who have packed the Tennessee Capitol this year to oppose legislation designed to upend the long-standing U.S. constitutional right to free public education for children, regardless of immigration status. It’s a protection established by the landmark 1982 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Plyler v. Doe, which struck down a Texas law that sought to deny enrollment to any student not “legally admitted” into the country.

“I am the son of immigrant parents who have shown me to respect and value everyone,” Felipe Jimenez told lawmakers earlier this year, speaking on behalf of the impact the bill would have on his peers. “Just like me and all the kids in this country, we have the right to dream and make those dreams come true. The right to an education should not be taken away from us because of our immigration status.”

A growing number of conservative leaders are pushing states to overturn Plyler v. Doe — including the conservative think tank The Heritage Foundation. This year, Tennessee’s Republican lawmakers appear the most willing to take up the cause by advancing legislation that directly contradicts the Supreme Court’s decision and would spark a legal battle that supporters hope will not only go before the high court but also allow justices to reverse the ruling.

GOP-led states have introduced a plethora of anti-immigration bills following President Donald Trump’s reelection and his subsequent moves to aggressively deport immigrants who have entered the U.S. illegally. But few have followed Tennessee’s lead to focus on revoking public education from children, and none have made it out of committee.

An uphill fight but a different Supreme Court

The Republican-controlled Tennessee Senate has approved a proposal requiring proof of legal residence to enroll in public K-12 public schools and allowing schools to either turn away students who fail to provide proper documentation or charge them tuition. The House version differs by letting public schools check immigration status, rather than requiring it.

The two versions will need to be reconciled before they can head to Republican Gov. Bill Lee’s desk. If it passes, the legislation is all but certain to face a lawsuit.

The sponsors of the proposal have largely downplayed denying children the right to education, but instead have focused on the fiscal impact states are facing in educating children residing in the U.S. illegally.

“It’s been argued that undocumented illegal aliens pay sales tax and property tax,” said Republican Sen. Bo Watson, the backer of the bill in the Senate. “True. But one doesn’t know if those payments come close to offsetting the additional costs. We argue they do not.”

It’s unknown how many undocumented children live in Tennessee, and it’s unclear if the proposal would result in any savings. When Texas made similar economic arguments in the Plyler case, it was rejected by the court.

Lawmakers and other conservative supporters repeatedly point to the 5-4 vote that determined Plyler in 1982, stressing the narrow decision means there is wiggle room to overturn the precedent — particularly under the current Supreme Court that has been open to reversing legal precedent, including on the right to abortion.

“It doesn’t take one too long to figure out that there’s a strong appetite by the conservatives on the Supreme Court to overturn precedent,” said Brett Geier, a professor of educational leadership at Western Michigan University. “And where does it come from? It starts with the states.”

The first test against the Plyler decision came in 1994 in California. Voters there approved a proposition prohibiting immigrants in the country without legal authorization from receiving public health care, education or other social services. That law was overturned.

In 2011, the Plyler precedent was challenged again after Alabama lawmakers required schools to determine student immigration status. That statute was eventually blocked after a legal challenge resulted in a settlement.

“I don’t see real debates about this. I see symbolic measures that are supported by some groups of Republican legislators,” said Thomas Saenz, president of the law firm Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, which successfully defended the plaintiffs before the Supreme Court in the Plyler case.

“They do trot up same old arguments from the 1970s about the burden of the costs, etc., etc.,” Saenz added. “They never balance that against the benefit of taxes being paid by these kids and their parents.”

For children, the fight turns personal

For months, as GOP lawmakers have defended the legislation, the tone of those who have shown up to fight against the bill has often turned emotional. Students have broken down in tears, distraught over their classmates being removed from their school and worries over who might be next.

As the Senate voted earlier this month, 12-year-old Silvestre Correa Del Canto stood outside in the crowded second floor of the Capitol with his mother, alarmed that the legislation could hurt children who don’t make the decisions about where they live and could impact their lives for years.

His family brought him to Nashville when he was 3 from Santiago, Chile. He now attends a public middle school that was originally a segregated school for African Americans. He connected that legacy to the Tennessee legislation.

“I feel like we’ve worked a lot to be connected again, people with people and going to school together,” Correa Del Canto, a sixth grader, said. “And I feel like that would be just going steps back, just going back in time and like losing all that we’ve worked for.”

___

Associated Press writer David Lieb contributed from Jefferson City, Missouri.



Source link

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
admin
  • Website

Related Posts

What to know as Trump administration targets tuition breaks for students without legal status

June 5, 2025

New York won’t rescind Native American mascot ban despite Trump threat

June 5, 2025

Foreign students accepted to Harvard in limbo under Trump ban

June 5, 2025

International student enrollment becomes a liability for Ivy League colleges

June 5, 2025

Teacher in Nigeria loses dozens of relatives and pupils in devastating floods

June 5, 2025

Trump moves to block US entry for Harvard-bound foreigners

June 4, 2025
Add A Comment
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Don't Miss
Billionaires

Mamdani Doesn’t Think We Should Have Billionaires. Here’s Why That Will Never Happen.

July 8, 2025

Here’s what’s been proposed—and why it never happens. Fresh off his shellacking of former New…

How The Blake Lively Saga Led A Billionaire To Shut Down His Foundation

July 7, 2025

This Florida Homebuilding Billionaire Doesn’t Own Any Stocks Or Bonds

July 5, 2025

NYC’s Robin Hood Charity Condemns Newly-Passed Senate Bill. Its Billionaire Donors Are Staying Mum

July 3, 2025
Our Picks

Franck Sorbier fuses Andean splendor with Parisian pageantry

July 9, 2025

The 5 best vehicles for campers, according to Edmunds

July 9, 2025

Trump’s big bill cuts Medicaid, SNAP: How it could affect babies

July 9, 2025

A simple recipe for tsukudani, an everyday Japanese side dish to eat with hot rice

July 9, 2025

Subscribe to Updates

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news

Subscribe my Newsletter for New Posts & tips Let's stay updated!

About Us
About Us

Welcome to World-Forbes.com
At World-Forbes.com, we bring you the latest insights, trends, and analysis across various industries, empowering our readers with valuable knowledge. Our platform is dedicated to covering a wide range of topics, including sports, small business, business, technology, AI, cybersecurity, and lifestyle.

Our Picks

After Klarna, Zoom’s CEO also uses an AI avatar on quarterly call

May 23, 2025

Anthropic CEO claims AI models hallucinate less than humans

May 22, 2025

Anthropic’s latest flagship AI sure seems to love using the ‘cyclone’ emoji

May 22, 2025

Subscribe to Updates

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news

Subscribe my Newsletter for New Posts & tips Let's stay updated!

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
© 2025 world-forbes. Designed by world-forbes.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.